Nick Williams was a student of mine a few years ago and has become a good friend. He has his own today.com blog Celluloid Psychosis where he reviews pretty much everything he watches. He’s a devote of everything from Jean Claude Van Damme to cinematic surrealism to out and out guttertrash. And most importantly for you ladies, he’s single and ready to mingle!
So here is the Nick Williams list of the best and worst of 2008!
TOP 10 MOVIES OF 2008:
(Note: This is a more of a “preliminary” list. I’ll be posting a bigger, revised version on my own blog in the near future.)

10. HELLBOY II: THE GOLDEN ARMY - While DARK KNIGHT may win out as best superhero flick of the year in most people’s eyes, I’d say it’s a close tie between that and Guillermo del Toro’s sequel to his underrated supernatural fantasy about a demonic government agent vanquishing sinister forces. I’d say this may even be better than the first (and that’s coming from somebody who loves the first). Del Toro once again proves himself to be a master at evoking a sense of wonder with his films, weaving a concrete adventure with plenty of fun action and enticing fantasy imagery, but also plenty of pathos and heartwarming characters.

9. DARK KNIGHT - Well, I guess it’s pretty much mandatory that this be included in any end of year list at this point. But yes, the second installment in the rebooted Batman franchise is an excellent superhero movie, more than likely one of the best, although honestly I think I still prefer BATMAN BEGINS over it. The film reinforces that director Christopher Nolan’s decision to reject the fantastical, over-the-top (and in some cases blatantly homoerotic) style of previous adaptations and apply a grounded, more realistic approach was definitely the best, as it seems to be the one most suited for the material. The story is mature and intelligent, the action gritty and visceral, Christian Bale is again awesome as the billionaire-turned-vigilante Bruce Wayne (and I sincerely think one of this generation’s best actors), as well as the rest of the cast being strong (especially Aaron Eckhart). Then of course there’s Heath Ledger’s turn as The Joker. So much has already been said about his demented performance that I won’t go in depth on it, but yes it does steal the show.

8. RED - The latest in a recent line of adaptations of the works of horror/suspense writer Jack Ketchum might very well be the best, if not at least the most accurate. The riveting, nearly Oscar-worthy lead performance by Brian Cox is glue that holds together this revenge drama about a man on a quest for justice for the cold-blooded murder of his beloved dog. Its bleak tone and avoidance of thriller conventions almost brought to mind NO COUNTRY FOR OLD MEN for me.

7. DIARY OF THE DEAD - Fuck CLOVERFIELD, George A. Romero’s latest effort in the zombie genre that he created is the true horror “verite” film of the year (along with the Spanish [REC], but it hasn’t been released yet so I’m not counting it). Instead of just using the “found footage” premise as a marketing ploy like so many others, Romero is able to use it as a vehicle to intelligently explore how the mass media and technology can affect the reality of events. I think it might be the best horror movie I’ve seen this year.

6. BIG BANG LOVE, JUVENILE A - Japanese maverick Takashi Miike is definitely one of my all-time favorite filmmakers. Many people, including Miike himself, have deemed this his magnum opus. While I may not completely agree, this definitely is up there as one of his best efforts, a somber existential prison drama with an underlying homoeroticism. A surreal production design reminiscent of German expressionism, unique direction, and overall otherworldly tone.
5. RAMBO - Sly Stallone continues his solid comeback, following his sincere conclusion to the ROCKY franchise, with a reboot of his other famous character. Like with ROCKY BALBOA, people expected a pathetic, laughable vanity piece with a past-his-prime star longing to relive his days as an action hero. But instead we get a mature commentary on war wrapped up in an action flick that is dark, savage, grim, and grounded in a harsh reality. Stallone does away with the macho patriotic fantasy of the earlier sequels and harks back to the bitter, cynical tone of FIRST BLOOD. This is the true John Rambo, a warrior who is self-loathing, weary, and psychologically embattled. I think this is personally the best action film I’ve seen in years.

4. THERE WILL BE BLOOD - Paul Thomas Anderson’s gloomy drama that explores the conflict between business and spirituality and how the extremes of each can corrupt is an eerie, poignant tour de force. Consummate acting by Daniel Day-Lewis, solid direction, and a mesmerizing sound design.

3. PHILOSOPHY OF A KNIFE - Andrey Iskanov might very well be the best filmmaker working in the underground today. He is willing to go farther artistically than most micro-budget directors are these days and has the gift to take minuscule resources and turn them into arresting and disturbing opuses of a unique, imaginative vision. While his previous experimental horror films dealt with the thin boundaries of reality, this epic documentary delves into humanity’s capacity for sheer depravity and sadism by examining the macabre experiments conducted by the Japanese army Unit 731 during World War II. The result is not just a movie, but a hypnotically hellish experience.

2. THE FALL - Tarsem Singh’s follow-up to THE CELL took 6 years to complete and was shot in over 18 countries, but despite its epic proportions it was swept under the rug for a couple years and dumped into a puny release where it was utterly ignored. It’s a damn shame, because it’s a beautiful, spellbinding film that evokes the works of Guillermo del Toro and Terry Gilliam in how it allegorically blends wondrous fairy tale fantasy and poignant coming-of-age drama.

1. WALL-E - Like a lot of people, I was completely caught unawares by this. The early trailers did nothing but inspire annoyance (and mild loathing because it looked like they had ripped off Johnny Five from SHORT CIRCUIT) and I didn’t have an iota of desire to see it. To me it looked like another empty Pixar exercise in making a quick buck by doing nothing but pandering to their child audience’s limited intelligence. But after its overwhelmingly positive reception, I decided to see if I was wrong, and guess what? I was! WALL-E is a film that completely surpasses typical family fare to be a sci-fi masterpiece. The film had an enormous effect on me on all possible levels - visually, emotionally, and intellectually. The animation is flawless and striking, the characters and story heartwarming, but what makes this a noteworthy Disney picture is the fact that it managed to get away with a subtle but scathing satire that comments on our own rampant consumerism (I’m surprised conservative parents haven’t complained about it attacking a value system that they are probably trying to program their children with. Then again, it’s probably not surprising it goes over most attention-deficient audiences collective heads). I certainly would never predict I’d say this, but I believe this was the best film I saw all year, and I think possibly even the best thing Disney has ever done.
Honorable mentions:
HAROLD & KUMAR ESCAPE FROM GUANTANAMO BAY - The sequel to the hilarious buddy comedy HAROLD & KUMAR GO TO WHITE CASTLE surpasses its predecessor, thanks to some biting political satire. The title characters, as well as others (including a returning Neil Patrick Harris as himself), are great, goofy enough to be funny but not so dumb they aren’t relatable, which is a key factor that most movies of this genre have completely forgotten these days. I think it’s the funniest comedy I saw this year.
THE STRANGERS - Looking back on the year, I noticed that the pickings for horror films were extremely slim. There’s only a small handful of titles that really stick out in my mind, but the aforementioned DIARY OF THE DEAD and this taut home invasion thriller are a couple that are near the top. Unlike most works in the genre, it bypasses the blood n’ guts to deliver some genuine suspense and sympathetic performances by Liv Tyler and Scott Speedman (not that there’s anything wrong with the blood n’ guts).
TOP 5 WORST FILMS OF 2008:

5. 88 MINUTES - Al Pacino, still looking tired and burnt out like he usually does these days, and still doing the same kind of manic performance he has for years, headlines this insipid thriller that is completely devoid of thrills. It’s a joke that’s been utilized in several reviews, but it’s so true I have to reiterate it: this movie makes 88 minutes feel like 88 hours. The pace just slogs leisurely through the morass of the pedestrian storyline without any remotely effective suspense or action, but being sure to hit every cliche along the way. Not to mention it has one of the weakest uses of the R rating ever: a quick flash of female nudity, one F word, and some mild violence, that’s all. About the only good thing it has going for it are a couple of unintentionally hilarious moments (like the opening credits), and a bevy of eye candy, with the gorgeous Alicia Witt, Leelee Sobieski, and Deborah Kara Unger, but nothing is really done with either of them.

4. 10,000 BC - If you’re going to make a mindless popcorn flick (which director Roland Emmerich has made a career of doing), that’s fine, but you damn well better at least make it amusing. This half-assed caveman flick was about as exciting as watching paint dry. I had to struggle to stay awake during this turd in the theater. Emmerich’s best movie is still the Jean-Claude Van Damme actioner UNIVERSAL SOLDIER.
3. MOTHER OF TEARS - God, what a disappointment, what an utter fucking disappointment. I sat through this dreck twice (actually one-and-a-half times): first on DVD then again in the theater as part of a Halloween horror movie marathon. The first time I was dispirited as I had been looking forward to the conclusion to Dario Argento’s Three Mothers trilogy, but found some mild amusement despite the major flaws. The second time around though those flaws became so glaring they were intolerable, and I left midway through the movie. Where can I even begin with what’s wrong here? How about the story, which is a total mess, with huge holes in logic and plot structure. Sure, even Argento’s classic works don’t have a great sense of realism or rationality, but they have their own kinds of abstract logic which help create a dreamlike mystique. Here, it’s just executed all wrong, and there are scenes and half-baked plot points that are wholly laughable, some even entering Harry PotterSUSPIRIA territory, and lame-ass dialogue. There’s the cheesy CGI and intrusive overwrought music which sounds like something from a third-rate black metal band, and the witch who’s supposed to be all-powerful and behind all the mayhem but looks like nothing but a naked goth chick in a dirty t-shirt sprinkled with glitter. Then there’s the goddamn monkey, which does nothing but elicit chuckles. It was obvious that Argento was trying to reference his past films in order to appeal to fans, but when somebody tries recycling his own material, it’s never a good sign. The thing that really irks me is that this is supposed to be a sequel to , which is an absolute masterpiece and one of my favorite all-time horror films. Dario, a former Italian master of the genre, had been on a steady decline in recent years with tepid efforts like TRAUMA and STENDHAL SYNDROME, but I would go bat for those in an instant over this miserable debacle.

2. LOST BOYS: THE TRIBE - This direct-to-video sequel of the 80’s cult classic was completely unwarranted and is a worthless piece of shit whose only redeemable factor is some unintentional hilarity, inspired mainly by the blatant incestuous overtones.

1. THE LOVE GURU - God, I don’t even know where to begin with this atrocity, except that it’s an all-out assault on human intelligence and should be considered an act of cultural terrorism perpetrated by Mike Myers. Seriously, the guards at Guantanamo and Abu Ghraib should dispense with waterboarding and consider this as a new means of interrogation - it’s way more excruciating.
And that’s what Nick has for the year of 2008!